Antoinette Reed – Interim Store Manager

Antoinette “Toni” Reed has worked in numerous capacities at the Old Creamery over the past 15 years, with managerial experience in Prepared Foods and Center Store Operations. She has been a committed Creamery team member through many leadership transitions and is known throughout the Hilltowns for always going above and beyond to help fellow co-workers and community members.

Toni has worked as an solar consultant and is an avid crafter of jewelry and other fine nature-inspired creations. She is excited to have the opportunity to serve as interim store manager and take on the day-to-day responsibilities of store operations. Please get in touch with your questions and ideas!

Contact: gm@oldcreamery.coop or grocery@oldcreamery.coop


Sandra Segatti – Finance & Human Resources Manager

I grew up on the Jersey Shore and my husband and I were living in Westchester County, just 5 miles from the Indian Point Nuclear Plant. After raising our two kids we both were ready for a change. For 10 years we took road trips to different rural areas and we were thrilled when we first discovered the Hilltowns. We spent two years searching for property and our realtor would often bring us to the Creamery for lunch. We eventually purchased a small cottage in Middlefield and ate many of our meals at the Creamery while we fixed it up.  We absolutely love this place.

Before we moved here, I worked for nine years in accounting at the March of Dimes national headquarters.  I went to school for social work, but my first job was in accounting at a Manhattan investment firm. I’ve been in accounting ever since.

When not working I like to garden – we have 12 acres so I am outside a lot, hiking, walking the dog. I also read a lot – I especially like space operas and British mysteries.

Contact: bookkeeper@oldcreamery.coop


Cassie Kendall – Center Store & Marketing Assistant

Cassie is an assistant manager in the Grocery/Center Store handling day-to-day operations, the bulk and pre-order program, and overseeing all grocery departments. She also serves as our marketing and communications coordinator. Cassie has been working at the Creamery in various roles since February 2019. In her spare time she enjoys crafting and making art.

Contact: marketing@oldcreamery.coop


Noel Shears-Pennell – Kitchen Supervisor

Noel has worked at the Creamery for 22 years and has seen it all. She stays for the love of the community and the dear friends and family she works with. She calls it the island of misfit toys. When not in the kitchen whipping out yummy, beautiful food, she is probably hanging out with her awesome kid. She also enjoys gardening, crocheting, and long hikes through the woods.


Kim Bode – Deli Supervisor