Our Small Store Has It All!

Ordering your groceries through our Bulk & Case Club is a great way to save time and money while supporting The Creamery. Based on your inquiries, we can track down and order thousands of different products from our distributors, including products that we don’t normally stock on our shelves. Orders from the  Bulk & Case Club will receive a 5% discount from our newly lowered retail prices. In appreciation to the ongoing support of our Member-Owner community, Co-Op Creamery Members will receive an additional 5% discount, for a total of 10% off shelf pricing.

Favorite brand of pretzels? Olive oil? Toothpaste? Need a bushel of apples or ten pounds of dried shiitake mushrooms?  While many of our available items have changed with the conversion to our new primary distributor, we can certainly help you track down a workable equivalent and save you the hassle of driving to another store.

Old Creamery “Bulk & Case Club” 

How To Place An Order:

1. To search the current Bulk & Case Club catalog, visit our online spreadsheet:

You can search for products by name, brand, or category. A couple of tips on browsing the catalogue:

  •  The items are sorted by brand alphabetically A-Z.
  • To search through the catalogue type CTRL-F. That will bring up a search bar and you can search by keyword. i.e. type “Bulk: and it will take you to the bulk section. 
  • Once you are in the general section of your search result you may have to scroll through a few items to find the one you’re looking for.
  • Please note this is NOT a list of every item carried by AGNE. This is a list of our most frequently received pre-orders along with AGNE’s top moving items. We will continue to add to this list as customers provide feedback about items they’re looking for. If there is something that you are looking for that isn’t on this list please send us an email, with the brand and item description, and we will get back to you as soon as we can: oldcreamerycenterstore@gmail.com

2. When you find the product you would like to order, fill out the Online Ordering Form: Here

You can print out the paper form: Here 

You only need to submit one form for multiple items. Simply follow the format and instructions below for each item ordered and enter the information in the item entry section below. Press enter to start a new line/paragraph for additional products

If your product is carried by AGNE, please include the AGNE item code from the third column of the sheet. (Note: If you have the product you want to reorder in your possession, and don’t want to comb through the catalogue, you may use the UPC code located on the product packaging instead.)

If your product is NOT carried by AGNE, please submit the UPC code (found under the barcode) if the product has one.  Be sure to use all numbers including leading and ending zeros. If the product does not have a barcode, please describe it to the best of your ability and request a confirmation call so that we can be sure to order the correct product.

Please submit orders in this format:

Brand, Item Description, Product Code/UPC, Pack/Size, Order Quantity 

Example: Cascadian Farms, Frzn Peas OG, 0-185623, 12/8oz.,  x 1 cs.

3. Give your paper Bulk & Case Club order form to a cashier or submit your form online. You will receive a phone call from the store when your order is ready for pickup. Please note that our storage space is extremely limited, especially for perishable items. 

AGNE Orders must be submitted by Sunday at 8:00 PM for pickup the following Thursday after 4:00 PM.  

AGNE currently does not accept returns after 24 hours of delivery. Please verify your order at pickup to confirm it is the correct item and quantity.

4. To pick up your order, simply notify the cashier. They will retrieve your form and you may pay for your item(s). If the item is particularly heavy, we can load it out to you directly from our delivery door by the ATM.

Thank you for Ordering!  For additional help navigating the system, please call the store and ask for Jeremiah or Lloyd. Or you can email oldcreamerycenterstore@gmail.com

Please share your feedback and help us spread the word!